
There was a woman who lived on our
street. She seemed fine. Normal person. She didn’t seem given to strange conceits
or over concern with conspiracies. She wasn’t given to buttonholing people in
public, just so you know. None of this was anything she brought on herself.
I got to know her a little bit
because she had a little backyard garden and I had a little backyard garden,
and there was only a small fence separating our gardens. So, naturally, we got
to talking and I guess she finally considered me to be a trustworthy person.
So, one day I was out pulling a few
weeds out of the raised beds, when I noticed her come out of her back door. She
didn’t come right over to the fence. She stood there looking vacant, maybe even
frightened.
I said, “Hi, Susan. How are you
today? Nice day.”
She looked at me and frowned a
little. She looked like she was considering something.
“It is a nice day,” Susan said
faintly, still frowning.
“Is everything alright?” I asked
her. I felt a little pushy saying that, but she seemed to be distressed.
“I don’t know,” she said, looking at
me like she wanted to say something, but wasn’t sure whether she should. She
shrugged a little. “Honestly, I don’t know..”
“Look,” I said. “We’re just a couple
of grandmas. You’re alone over there, except for your cats. Who are you going
to tell? You may as well tell me. I don’t think anything you say would be a big
surprise to me.” I stood with my hands folded, head tilted, smiling
encouragingly.
“OK, Penny. OK. You know those two
cats I have? They are identical, you know? Even I can’t tell them apart. It’s
been kind of a joke. Not very funny
today,” she said.
“How so?” I said.
“Well, last night I went to bed as
usual. But, before I went to bed I locked both doors. The basement door is
always locked. Always. I checked all the windows, even though it’s been warm, I
made sure they were all closed and latched. The place was secure, you know?”
She frowned.
“Of course,” I said, wondering what
she was getting to with this recitation.
“I don’t let my cats outdoors,” she
said.
“I know, and I don’t blame you at
all,” I said.
“I made sure that I knew where both
cats were before I went to bed,” Susan continued.
“I do the same with my two,” I said.
“You might think I am insane,” she
said. “But, I’m not.”
“I would never think you are insane,
Susan,” I said, beginning to get a weird creepy feeling standing there in the
early morning sunlight. I didn’t know why, but I felt a cold pickle on my arms.
I rubbed them and waited.
“This morning, Penny, I went to feed
my cats. Instead of my two, there were three cats in my house all precisely
identical. This is insane. One of them is not a natural cat and I can’t tell
which one it is. They all ate and acted exactly the same!” She shuddered a
little.
“How horrible! I see exactly what
you mean!” I whispered.
“One of them is some kind of
manifestation, of what, I don’t know,” she said. “And I want it out of my
house! But I can’t decide which two are mine,” she wailed.
“What will you do?” I said.
“I don’t know. I don’t really want
to go back in there with that. Whatever it is!” she cried.
“I’ll come with you. Why don’t we go
look at them together and see what we think,” I suggested. Honestly, I was as
curious as heck. I wanted a look at those cats in the worst way.
“OK,” she said, and I walked out of
my alley gate and over to her gate off the alley and into her back yard. She
waited by her back door.
She went ahead of me, of course. We
both stepped into the back of the kitchen. I closed the door carefully behind myself.
Since we made a little noise coming
into the house, her cats came to us as cats do when you come into the house.
Two rather rotund, absolutely identical brown tabbies. They wound themselves
around her feet, then came and sniffed me too. They knew me. I’d been in that
kitchen before.
“Where’s the other one, Susan?” I
said.
“She was just here when I came out
into the garden,” she said, looking a little sick.
We searched Susan’s house in detail.
Every closet, every room and cupboard. We searched the basement and the attic.
We never found a third cat in that
house.
“I’m not insane, and I can count to
three,” she said, as if in a trance.
“I know you’re not,” I said. “But it
looks like everything is back to normal,” I said hopefully.
“Oh, no! It’s not! Even though there
are two of them again, I will never know if one of mine has been spirited away by
the fairies, and I am left with an unnatural creature which looks like one of mine,
but isn’t! And on top of that, I will never be able to tell if one of them is
that awful creature or which one it could be!” She stared at me, horrified.
The best thing I could think of to
tell her was that probably the fey kitty had left by the same way it had gotten
into her house, and that it was just something messing with her.
I sure hoped that was true.
🙀